Let's talk

How to best approach the insurance market for smaller schemes

×
Video - Podcast
Translations from English are done by AI, without human oversight, and may not be accurate
Pensions & benefits Pension risk transfer Post-transaction and wind-up support DB pensions Strategic journey planning
Hazy flowers in front of the sky

Following dramatic improvements in pension scheme funding levels over the last five years, many trustees and sponsors are weighing up the endgame options for their schemes.

With The Pensions Regulator recently estimating that over 60% of defined benefit schemes are now fully funded on a buy-out basis, many are considering if now is the right time to transfer the responsibility for paying their members’ benefits to a UK life insurer.

Lately, the vast majority of insurance transactions have been sub-£100m, which we often refer to as ‘smaller’ schemes. For example, in 2025 over 80% of buy-in transactions by number (18% by volume) were sub-£100m and over 30% were sub-£10m. There are special considerations that trustees and sponsors need to be aware of to execute this type of transaction well.

So, what should trustees and sponsors of smaller schemes be looking out for?

In this blog, Ruth Ward and David Stewart – partners in our Pension Risk Transfer team – share their insights on how competitive the insurance landscape is for smaller schemes and what to expect if you’re thinking about insuring and then winding-up your scheme. LCP has advised over 180 transactions under £100m since 2014 – including 23 over 2025, transacted with seven different insurers.

Can smaller schemes achieve competitive insurance pricing? 

Yes, absolutely!  

Our analysis shows that insurance pricing reached exceptional levels over the first nine months of 2026, with highly attractive pricing continuing into Q4 2026 for smaller (as well as larger) schemes who approach the market in the right way – more on that in a moment.

The key drivers for current attractive pricing are record insurer capacity exceeding demand and a growing contribution from newer insurer entrants, leading to intense competition for both larger and smaller transactions.  

Interestingly, as our chart illustrates, the number of smaller scheme transactions has increased significantly over recent years, from 77 in 2020 up to 303 in 2025 (as shown by the transactions shaded blue and grey), driving the rapid growth in total buy-in transaction numbers over this period. A key facilitator of insurers meeting the strong demand from smaller schemes has been the development of insurer streamlined offerings which have significantly expanded their capacity to quote at this size.

This means that this once under-served segment is now flourishing, with more insurers than ever bidding on smaller schemes.

Which UK insurers are quoting for smaller schemes? 

In short, all of them. 

Although, some insurers retain a preference for larger transactions, they are increasingly interested in the smaller schemes, with all insurers transacting sub-£100m schemes in 2025.  

Our chart shows that Just’s and Aviva’s dominance in the sub-£100m segment remained evident last year and over H1 2026; however, there was a notable uptick by newer insurer entrants (JAB Pensions, Prudential and Royal London and Utmost), as well as increased participation by insurers such as Rothesay who have previously focused almost entirely on larger transactions.

Having multiple insurers competing for smaller schemes is good news for trustees and sponsors, and not just from the perspective of driving more competitive pricing. You might be surprised by just how different the insurers are to each other, so the choice of multiple insurers can help you to better meet your specific objectives and the needs of your members.

Ruth Ward Partner

To maximise the number of these insurers participating in your process and drive the most competitive pricing, it’s important to take the right steps to be prioritised by them amongst the hundreds of other smaller schemes also seeking insurance pricing. Our 'Beat the Triage' guide shares how you can prepare your scheme thoroughly for market and present the best business case for an insurer to quote for your scheme, with real-life examples of how you can influence the factors that insurers care about.

What about getting strong contractual terms? 

Getting best pricing is only one half of the equation – achieving a robust contract is also important.  

The terms in the contract will dictate the benefits for your members for decades to come and also govern how the trustees’ interactions with the insurer will work. As you consider insurance, it’s important to be aware of the potential risks and pitfalls. 

As an example, the contract will set out how easy it is to make any adjustments needed to the data and benefits insured. This can be important if new members come to light whom you’d like to add, or if there are surplus assets to distribute to members. Not having the right contract provisions here could be a potential blocker to allow your scheme to eventually wind-up.

But, as a smaller scheme, there is much less scope for bespoke negotiation on insurers’ standard contractual terms, which can mean you end up with sub-optimal terms.

To help our clients get around this and allow smaller schemes to access better terms, we have pre-negotiated contracts in place with all insurers providing terms more akin to those available on larger transactions.

Over 140 schemes and counting have now used these pre-negotiated contracts and transacted through our streamlined service, through which we have now secured over £6.5bn of liabilities for smaller schemes.

A key challenge for smaller schemes is being crowded out of an increasingly busy market. LCP’s streamlined service can help you maximise insurer engagement to overcome this challenge. It also helps you achieve better pricing and commercial terms with certainty on fees and timescales through a carefully structured process that all the insurers appreciate.

David Stewart Partner

How long does the whole insurance and wind-up process take?

Insurance transactions and wind-ups are highly complex and strategic projects which typically take a number of years to complete – and so many trustee boards and sponsors find bringing a specialist buy-out and wind-up adviser and an experienced professional trustee on board hugely valuable.

A well-prepared scheme could insure in as little as five months using our streamlined service – but that is just the first step of the journey.

The following key steps are necessary to then take your scheme to wind-up – and these can vary hugely between schemes:

Your scheme will typically have a period of 12-24 months following the insurance transaction to verify and finalise its data and benefits. The insurance can then be adjusted to reflect these changes, subject to a balancing premium or refund. 

No two schemes are the same, but it’s not uncommon for there to be wider aspects to deal with as part of the wind-up process, eg historical annuities that do not fully match individuals’ scheme benefits or AVCs that need to be transferred to an alternative arrangement.

Depending on your scheme rules, legislation, and views of key stakeholders, these may be used to augment member benefits, pay scheme expenses, and/or returned to the sponsor. This is a complex area with a knock-on impact on timelines where member consultation is required – so the right advice and experience are essential.

Insurers all have their own processes and potentially limited slots each month, so it’s important to work with a wind-up specialist who understands these and can help you plan ahead to avoid months of delays.

Even once the insurer has issued individual policies to members, there are final tasks to achieve scheme wind-up, including preparing final scheme accounts and notifying statutory bodies.

Concluding thoughts  

In many ways the market has never been more attractive for smaller schemes interested in insuring their members – with pricing, competition, and choice of insurer better than ever. 

To get the best possible outcome for your scheme and its members it is however vital that you are smart about how you approach the insurers – and put yourself in the best position to secure both excellent pricing and competitive terms that will protect you and your members. 

Throughout, it is important to always look ahead to not just the insurance transaction but the full journey to wind-up (if that is the trustees’ and sponsor’s ultimate goal).  

These are complex multi-year projects which can have many pitfalls but with an experienced risk transfer adviser and the right experience and skills on your trustee board, they are a well-trodden path to secure your members’ benefits for the future.