Let's talk

World order – a new formation emerges?

×
Video - Podcast
Translations from English are done by AI, without human oversight, and may not be accurate
Investment Economy Policy & regulation
Desert under a starry sky

LCP’s investment conference – “From fragmentation to formation” – took place on 12 November. We listened to a series of fascinating presentations which included ideas such as a tongue-in-cheek proposal to tax nine-year-olds to help reduce the UK's national debt as well as a more serious argument encouraging UK investment, given that pension savers retire into an economy, not merely a pension pot.

In between these talks we also invited delegates to take part in an investment "game" on their phones.

A bit of fun? We hope so. But fun with a serious purpose and, as we’ll see, some very interesting results.

Having reviewed the results of our game here’s my take on things:

  • The world’s future is multipolar.

  • The US and China will be the most important blocs in that multipolar world.

  • America is starting to lag behind China in a way that would have been unthinkable just a few years ago.

  • China appears to have the economic edge on the factors we considered but there are other ways to look at the issue.

  • The EU may be the focus of a bloc in its own right but that’s less likely than for the US and China. Perhaps the lesson is that in a power rather than a rules-based world, hard power trumps soft power every time. The EU has a lot of the latter but not so much of the former at present.

  • Non-aligned status has always had its attractions but in an increasingly volatile world, maintaining such a position is likely to become more and more challenging.

  • Britain has to decide where its future lies and soon.

So, what did we ask people to do?

The game asked people to envision their world, their world order, 10 years from now. First, participants had to decide how many blocs – centres of power – might emerge over the coming decade. Individuals could choose up to 3 blocs centred on the US, China, the EU, along with a group of those countries expected to remain non-aligned to any particular bloc.

Players were then asked to place a number of countries in the different blocs. There are currently 195 recognised countries across the globe. Since the game was supposed to be fun rather than a test of endurance we pre-selected a subset of 18 nations which we believe captured key points of global significance across a number of dimensions including economic, geographic and demographic ones.

We gave participants a few details about each country, including its population as well as its GDP per capita just to help focus minds. And since it was supposed to be entertaining as well as informative, we also included a “fun fact” for each country. Did you know, for instance, that India has the world’s largest postal network, or that Mexico has the biggest Spanish-speaking population of any country? Me neither.

What did the collective wisdom of our conference delegates reveal?

World Order – A New Formation Emerges Room At A Glance

First that the world is moving from unipolar to multipolar. The results suggest that the unipolar world that emerged after the end of the Cold War, with the USA at the sole superpower at its centre, is well and truly dead. The view most commonly expressed is that two blocs will emerge, two led by the US and China along with a third grouping comprising non-aligned nations.

Two findings did stand out for me.

The first is that China was chosen as a bloc leader more often than the US. Ten years ago, such a result would have been extraordinary. Five years ago, a shock. Today, it probably falls into the surprising category. But no more than that. To me, it seems that as America appears to be drawing inwards, China is filling the spaces vacated.

What I also find intriguing is that a significant minority of participants believe that the EU will emerge as a bloc leader. The Union is evidently facing significant economic and competitive struggles as well as upcoming challenges to its political cohesion. If I look at the countries expected to be most likely to adhere to the EU when it is chosen as a bloc leader, it’s other middle size powers, such as the UK, Canada and Australia that are in that group. When you’re a (relatively) small creature and big beasts in the shape of the US and China are prowling around, maybe it’s best to stick together. And when making their selections, some conference delegates may have had in mind Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney’s January 2026 Davos World Economic Forum speech. In that speech, Carney noted that in an era of renewed great power rivalry, middle powers need to work together. As he noted:

“Countries that only negotiate bilaterally with hegemons negotiate from weakness.”

And perhaps rather more memorably he also observed that:

“Middle powers must act together because if you are not at the table, you are on the menu.”

As you might expect, and as I had hoped, there were countries for which there was a good degree of consensus as to how they would align and others where there was no clear agreement.

For example, you would be forgiven if you failed to raise an eyebrow when you see that the majority of players thought that Russia and Iran were most likely to be China aligned.

World Order – A New Formation Emerges Russia Alignment
World Order – A New Formation Emerges Iran Alignment

Russia and Iran: could recent history be overturned?

I was fascinated to see that there were small votes for both Russia and Iran being EU and US aligned in 10 years’ time. It brings to mind the words of another Prime Minister, this time a 19th century British one, Lord Palmeston, speaking at the time as Foreign Secretary, when he said:

"We have no eternal allies, and we have no perpetual enemies. Our interests are eternal and perpetual, and those interests it is our duty to follow."

So is a rapprochement possible with Iran and Russia. Who knows?

And then there are countries where the jury is definitely out as to which way they’ll jump, if they jump at all.

World Order – A New Formation Emerges Turkey Alignment

Turkey and India: keeping a foot in multiple camps

Turkey clearly sits at a geographic crossroads, literally straddling the physical gap between Europe and Asia. It performs the same trick on a number of other dimensions as well. It has strong economic ties to Europe but also to Russia and China. Militarily it is a key member of NATO whilst it also maintains significant defence links with Russia and has more recently established the Mecca Pact with Turkey and Pakistan.

World Order – A New Formation Emerges India Alignment

And then of course there’s India, the poster child for non-alignment. Overall, our audience believed that the most likely outcome is that it will be able to maintain that status over the coming decade, balancing the competing pressures and inducements placed upon it by the US and China to fall into their respective camps. What’s interesting though is that for those who think it will ultimately face one way rather than another, it’s considered three times more likely that India will plump for China rather than America. Again, and particularly given the number of border skirmishes there have been between these two neighbours, who would have thought that 10 or even 5 years ago?

World Order – A New Formation Emerges Uk Alignment

The UK: towards America or Europe?

The chart shows the continuing tension between the pull of the Atlanticists’ vision of a UK firmly in America’s orbit and one which hews towards the European mainland. A surprising number, to my mind at least, have a UK in 2036 aiming to maintain its distance and to balance the pressures that will undoubtedly be placed upon it, from each of the US, Europe and China. Given Mark Carney’s view of middle powers, will that be a tenable position? Prime Minister Andy Burnham’s recent pronouncements on closer EU ties suggest the question may have to be confronted sooner rather than later.

The big picture

The chart below shows the world by “leading alignment” (ie which of the US, China, the EU or non-aligned blocs our audience chose most often for the country in question) and shows the multipolar future expected for the world.

World Order – A New Formation Emerges Audience World Map

We can look at what our players’ bloc choices and bloc memberships allocations mean for the world in a variety of ways. Countries have been allocated to blocs on the basis of the one to which players assigned them most frequently. The three metrics below are essentially “starting positions” – ie what those figures are now rather than a prediction of what they’ll be in 2036.

First, take population.

World Order – A New Formation Emerges Population By Leading Alignment

The population accounted for by the different countries / blocs in our game is around 5.1 billion, or c.60% of the global total of about 8.2 billion. On this measure, China emerges as the “winner”, with an “aligned population” of approximately 2.1 billion, 2.2x and 4.8x bigger than that of the US and EU blocs respectively. If, as is sometimes said, demography is destiny, then China may be well on its way to fulfilling its ambitions – although that does rather overlook the fact that the country’s own population is ageing rapidly and there are other factors that can mitigate the impact of demographics, such as education, institutional resilience, technology and capital investment.

Second, take GDP.

World Order – A New Formation Emerges Estimated Gdp By Leading Alignment

Based upon estimated population and GDP per capita (on a Purchasing Parity Basis) we’ve estimated the aggregate total GDP across each of the different blocs. On this basis, China and the US are pretty much neck and neck, with the EU some way behind. Perhaps the US and its fellow bloc members can take some comfort from the fact that they are holding they own on this metric. Or can they? Don’t forget we’re looking at the numbers for the blocs as they are in 2026. While the US itself has experienced strong growth, China has – and is expected to continue to grow more strongly still – so that aggregate gap is only likely to become larger. The EU should probably be more worried; already a long way behind, it also has to contend in the future with China’s voracious appetite for eating not only the bloc’s lunch but also its breakfast and dinner in the form of the region’s car, green energy and capital goods sectors.

And finally, land area.

World Order – A New Formation Emerges Land Area By Leading Alignment

By this metric, the US bloc is ahead. Not perhaps the most important measure of the actual or potential power of a bloc. Still, it’s useful to have more of it rather than less. As is often attributed almost certainly apocryphally to Mark Twain, “buy land, they’re not making it anymore.”

The game was a bit of lighthearted entertainment but with some potentially serious implications.

Given that some questions you might want to ask yourself include:

  • What implications might the results of the game have for my investment portfolio?

  • Are the implications different for different asset classes?

  • If the world is splitting into blocs, how do I ensure that my investment portfolio is truly diversified?

  • What factors – other than population and GDP – (e.g. trade, defence, resources) would it be helpful to consider when thinking about what the world might look like in 10 years’ time?

  • Are there any other blocs which might emerge?

  • Which countries would I include in my list for inclusion on the blocs?

If you’d like to hear more about the results of the game or more from our macro experts, then just let us know and we’d be happy to help.